I Am Mary Jo Buttafuoco (2026 Lifetime Movie)
📺. Stream/Watch the Movie (Ad): Subscribe to the Lifetime Movie Club
Cast: Chloe Lanier, Dillon Casey, Mary Jo Buttafuoco
Director: Heather Hawthorn Doyle
Writer(s): Gregg McBride
➡️ Check out our YouTube Channel: Lifetime Uncorked: Lifetime Movie Reviews
🎧 Listen to the Lifetime Uncorked Podcast: Listen Now
🍷 Support the show with a $5 tip: https://ko-fi.com/patrickserrano
Accused: The Karen Read Story, Katie Cassidy, and Turtleboy? – Lifetime Uncorked
- Accused: The Karen Read Story, Katie Cassidy, and Turtleboy?
- It's A Wonderful Lifetime Preview, Brandy Norwood, Vivica A. Fox, and Airplane Movies?
- If I Run Lifetime Movie, Kat Graham, and Prayer Requests?
- Ice Road Killer Lifetime Movie, Christmas Thrillers, and Truckers
- You Better Watch Out, Christmas in July, and Bramblefest?
- The Nanny Sees All 2025 Lifetime Movie, Child Actor of the Year, and Golden Madison?
- I'm Your Biggest Fan Lifetime Movie, Hailey Duff Directs, and Beverley Mitchell?
Make a one-time donation
Make a monthly donation
Make a yearly donation
Choose an amount
Or enter a custom amount
Your contribution is appreciated.
Your contribution is appreciated.
Your contribution is appreciated.
DonateDonate monthlyDonate yearlySynopsis (via Lifetime)
For the first time ever, Mary Jo Buttafuoco tells her story in her own words. In May 1992, outside her Long Island home, Mary Jo was shot in the head by 17-year-old Amy Fisher – the mistress of her husband, Joey Buttafuoco.
Recap/Wine Thoughts
Based on a True Story
The movie starts with the infamous altercation between Mary Jo Buttafuoco and Amy Fisher. Mary Jo Buttafuoco was shot in the face by her husband’s teenage lover.
Mary Jo Buttafuoco herself gives a straight-to-camera testimonial for the first time, telling her story. In retrospect, she sees the red flags with her husband Joe that she didn’t see at the time.
The movie flashes back to Mary Jo Buttafuoco and Joe’s first meeting and wedding. They seem to have it all. Mary Jo Buttafuoco quickly becomes pregnant after that and is committed to raising a family. Joey isn’t ready and is a perpetual teenager, going out and buying Mary Jo Buttafuoco lavish gifts to make up for his neglectful ways.
Enter Amy Fisher, the Long Island Lolita. She seduces Joey, waits till she is legal in the state of New York, and sleeps with a guy named Steven to get a gun. The movie and Mary Jo Buttafuoco are clear that they think Amy Fisher is a convincing slutty teenager. Not a goomed and neglected minor. (It’s an interesting take in 2026; this movie is the personification of “Okay, Boomer.”
After a few failed attempts, Mary Jo Buttafuoco tells her story in her own words. Amy meets a guy named Peter at a party and finally gets the gun. She convinces him to be her getaway driver and shoots Mary Jo Buttafuoco on her doorstep.
Mary Jo Buttafuoco wakes up with a bullet lodged in her head and a long road to recovery. She is quick to confront Joey about his affair, on a notepad. Mary Jo Buttafuoco suffers from permanent hearing loss and has to wear an eye patch. Joey denies having an affair flat out.
Detectives piece things together and quickly entrap Amy Fisher with Joey’s help. The story becomes a tabloid sensation, and Mary Jo Buttafuoco blames Amy Fisher for everything and gives Joey a public pass. She stands by her man. (She was raised CATHOLIC in the 60s and was on a lot of pain pills.)
It even gets to the point of Joey and Mary Jo Buttafuoco being on set for one of the THREE TV movies of the time. Mary Jo Buttafuoco has no anonymity. Even SNL makes fun of her in their sketches.
Amy Fisher’s trial takes place over a year after the crime. Mary Jo Buttafuoco testifies against her and is emotional in court. The judges go OFF on Amy Fisher and sentence her to 5-15 years in prison.
At Joey’s trial, he pleads guilty, and Mary Jo Buttafuoco isn’t by his side. He gets 6 months. Gross.
Mary Jo Buttafuoco becomes depressed and addicted to pills. Her kids just want their mother to be happy, but Mary Jo Buttafuoco is in the depths of dark, intrusive thoughts. She gets rid of the pills and checks herself into a rehab clinic, where she hits rock bottom and goes to group therapy.
After Mary Jo Buttafuoco divorces Joey, her mother stops talking to her for 4 months. She obviously isn’t in touch with Joey or Amy Fisher. Mary Jo Buttafuoco says her story is about survival and raising her family with a second husband, whom they also divorced.
Finally, Mary Jo Buttafuoco gets surgery to smile again. Good for her!
STRAY Thought
This case and its media circus of it’s magnatuide would not be possible today. It really was a product of the time.
Overall rating
Number of Kills: None (0 knives)
Lifetime Tropes: AMY FISHER, cheating husband,
Enjoyment Level (1-5 scale)
🍷🍷 (2 Glasses of Wine)
Should you watch it?
Pour it up (Give it a shot)
Put a Cork in It (Skip It!)
What did you think of the movie? Let me know in the comments or on social media at @LifetimeUncorked and @patrickmiguel.
Inquiries | podcast@lifetimeuncorked.com
🍾 Your Support is appreciated. onate to keep the website going. hank you.
*Photo Credit: © 2026 A&E Television Networks, LLC
Let me know what you thought of the movie in the comments below or @lifetimeuncorked
Recap: We didn’t need another movie about a 16 year old girl getting groomed by a middle aged guido who wanted to cheat on his “stand by your man” wife. Nobody cares about Mary Jo 30+ years later. Really ridiculous movie by Lifetime.
Absolutely agree!